This past Saturday I celebrated my 29th birthday the only way I know how - eating. It was a day I'd been planning ever since Easter Weekend, when a post Hudson River run-lunch found me sweaty, soaked, sore and finally salivating over a roast turkey sub that far exceeded my wildest expectations and rather bluntly changed my life. So it was on Easter Sunday, as I walked home through Soho, amidst a school of smelly Spaniards, that I called my parents and said, "I know where I'm taking you next time you come to the city."
Fast-forward 3 weeks, and there we were, myself, my father, my mother, and my lovely wife-to-be, nestled snugly into a corner table at Torrisi's, mere minutes after its doors open to the public on a beautiful late April morn. Just footsteps from the sacred walls of Old St. Pat's on nearby Prince Street, like a dedicated priest bearing good tidings to his aging congregation, I was mentally prepping my culinary disciples for an experience that would be somewhat of an exorcism of everything that they once believed to be true.
Torrisi's Italian Specialties, in no more words than necessary, is what I've always been looking for and just didn't know it until now. A small, 18-seat parlor on the northern fringe of Little Italy dedicated to serving tried and true Italian American fare using the best American ingredients. If you don't believe them, take close note of the walls bedizened in packaged Progresso Bread Crumbs, and rows upon rows of unopened jars of New Jersey's own B&G peppers - here is your clue that you're into something good here.
Having arrived a few minutes after my parents, I already knew what to expect. Knowing my father, who, when it comes to food and waiting for it, has less self-control than Barney Frank at a Chuck E. Cheese's, I was expecting to arrive to find something already sitting on the table. Worse yet, I feared my father would be half-way into a sub and I'd miss all his juicy commentary.
Luckily this was not the case, sort of - I did arrive to my father having ordered, but was fortunate to have gotten there moments after our first masterpiece hit the table. What greeted me was a sight to be seen, an hommage to all things Italian American and a sparkling shrine to a realm of food that all but completely defined my culinary childood. It was indeed what we titled The Italian Sub, and it looked like this:
What we have here is what I venture to say is (half of) the best pure sub I've ever had. We bear witness to a same-day fresh Hero bread from neighborhood favorite Parisi's bakery cradling a mass of various salty ham and salami, draped delicately with a thin layer of provolone. What does it for me particulary at this stage in the game is the not-too-heavy portion of super-finely-shredded lettuce, paper-thin tomato and a smattering of sliced vinegary cherry peppers that finish off this work of art. I have always loved italian sandwiches, but often shunned the traditional "subs" that boasted shredded lettuce, tomato, oil and vinegar, and (gasp!) mayo mainly becuase too many Deli's in too many parts of the country have managed to ruin this ancient artform. But at Torrisi's, I've found salvation and am once again, a true believer.
The bread, the meat, the lettuce, the tomato, and the "deli spread" lathered on both top and bottom of the bread make this the best sub I've ever eaten. I'm not sure I can say anything else about it.
Had the meal ended here, I would've been more than satisified albeit still hungry. These days I sometimes still contemplate the true meaning of being an Ubereater, until times like this when I realize my amuse bouche is half of a 5-inch tall sub.
Next it was on to what I had been talking about all along: The Roast Turkey. You can get any sandwich you please at Torrisi's on either a round roll or a hero. I opted for the hero, and added roasted peppers to my mix. What I got, was what I had been dreaming about for weeks since my last visit. A beautiful heap of moist, 3/4 inch thick hunks of herb-blasted, house-made, falling- apart-on-itself turkey, shouldering thankfully a layer of roasted peppers, and more of that surgically sliced bouquet of lettuce and tomato. Oh and a tons of deli paste of course. This was dastardly delicious - juicy, crunchy, smooth, crispy - it has it all. It just has it all.

The turkey is unlike anything you've ever had. How could these sumptuous slabs of grainy, white-meat wonderfullness come from the same creature my family so readily banished from the Thanksgiving dinner table years ago. It's a question that needs no answer. And this is a sandwich that need not be spoken for any further.

Though caught up in the tumultuous turbulence of my toppling Turkey treat, I kept my whits about me enough to remember to order a nice heaping block of the eggplant parm, which has been taunting me from behind the glass-shielded countertop for way too long. It was my birthday and I'm freaking ordering it. Having mentally devoured this busty beaut from the moment I laid eyes on it, I could only hope it was half as satisfying as my beloved Turkey and the like. There was, as they say, only one way find out.
My order manifested itself in the form of this:

Like admiring the vast easterly view of the New York City skyline on that storied final approach into Newark Airport, this eggplant parm was simply breathtaking and easily the best I've ever had. Easily. Traditional to the nth degree, layer upon layer of thin, lightly-breaded slices of eggplant, interspersed with sweet red gravy spiked with fresh basil and a rogue piece of fresh mozzy, wears proudly the aftermath of gentle anoiting of grated Parmigiano. This is the eggplant parm we all dreamed of but never could actually attain. What do they do to the eggplant? God only knows.
It should go without saying then, that we couldn't stop eating it, which is why we ordered another piece. Though it doesn't surprise me knowing what I know now, this is another perfect example of how impeccably fresh ingredients treated properly make a classic favorite indefatiguably delicious.
For good measure, I also went ahead and splurged on a 1/2 lb of the house-made mozzy. I don't care who you are, or where you've been, or who you voted for, homemade mozzarella cheese is unlike anything you'll put in your mouth. Torrisi's is served as such, sliced into thirds and beached in a mixture of its own whey and a healthy dousing of extra virgin olive oil.
A succulent end to an overall spectacular birthday.
While it may be true that 2010 has been the most conservative for the Ubereater, it is also shaping up to be possibly the most fruitful and enlightening yet and I have Torrisi's to thank for that.
I think Mark, my main man behind the counter with whom I've gotten to know a bit after a few trips, sums it up best.
"Everything is good. These guys really know what they're doing."
He ain't kidding. And neither am I.